The film is generally described as a "dumpster fire" or "bargain-bin" production. Key criticisms include:

The film includes significant "vlogging" and YouTube-style commentary—notably from Shawn C. Phillips—which many found annoying and irrelevant to the actual story. Segment Breakdown

“American Sasquatch appears to be a bunch of shorts sloppily jammed together to make a "feature length" movie.” IMDb

Overall, unless you are a "completionist" of Bigfoot cinema, most Reviewers from Horror Society and IMDb suggest skipping this title in favor of better-produced cryptid documentaries or films. American Sasquatch (Review) - Horror Society