The episode has sparked intense debate among viewers and critics:
Many fans found the ending "unsatisfactory," particularly how supporting characters like Gene, Sarah, and Leslie had their storylines abruptly "fall flat" without a proper send-off. Eps13In the Dark - Season 4
In a chillingly calm sequence, Murphy cleans herself up at a convenience store, discarding her bloody clothes before she and Felix ride off into the sunrise with her guide dog, Pretzel. Critical and Fan Reception The episode has sparked intense debate among viewers
While some critics labeled it one of the worst finales ever due to its "horror-flick" tone and lack of legal consequences, others felt it was a fitting, if tragic, end for Murphy—a character whose life was always defined by trauma rather than a "fairytale" redemption. Despite the divisive ending, the show is remembered
Despite the divisive ending, the show is remembered for its strong representation and the compelling, messy evolution of Murphy and Felix’s ride-or-die friendship.
Reviewers from IMDb and TV Fanatic offer deeper dives into the series' sudden cancellation and its impact on the finale's pacing. In the Dark series finale review: Well, that happened
The series finale of In the Dark , Season 4, Episode 13 ("Please Shine Down on Me"), concludes the show on a dark, divisive note that shifts away from its crime-thriller roots toward a raw, tragic exploration of trauma. The Ultimate Revenge