Georgie’s dreams of a romantic getaway are cut short when his girlfriend's father sees the inside of the van and immediately forces him to return it.
Sheldon’s competitive nature flares up when he realizes Paige is just as good, if not better, at Bible trivia. They engage in a fierce race to name the twelve apostles and memorize verses, all for the sake of a "John the Baptist" pencil topper.
The tension reaches a boiling point when Sheldon's social obliviousness leads him to say something particularly insensitive about her family. The result? Paige delivers a solid punch that leaves Sheldon on the floor, much to Missy’s amusement. Georgie’s "Chariot of Love"
As Sheldon tries to irritate Paige by using the Bible to "humiliate" her, Paige reveals she's actually rebelling because of her parents' divorce.